Limitation of Shipowners’ Liability (LLMC 1976) and the Procedure for Constituting a Fund in Türkiye
Limitation of shipowners’ liability allows high-value maritime claims to be met within a specified ceiling. Following a collision, damage to a port facility or cargo damage, a timely decision on whether to constitute a fund in Türkiye may affect the vessel’s ability to continue its voyage and the status of security just as directly as the correct calculation of the LLMC 1976 limit.
Limitation does not mean that no debt or liability exists. It is necessary to examine separately whether the claim falls within the LLMC, who is entitled to limit liability, what limit applies and whether the right to limit has been lost.
This bulletin provides a detailed examination of the LLMC 1976 and the fund constitution procedure in Türkiye, addressing the key questions arising in this context. The principal issues to be examined in this bulletin are as follows:
- How Is the LLMC 1976 Regime Applied in Türkiye?
- Which Maritime Claims Are Subject to Limitation?
- When Is the Right to Limit Liability Lost?
- Current LLMC Liability Limits
- Special Limits Applicable in Türkiye
- Is Constitution of a Limitation Fund Mandatory?
- Procedure for Constituting a Limitation Fund in Türkiye
- Cash or Security Option
- How Is the Competent and Jurisdictionally Proper Court Determined?
- Effect of the Fund on Claims and Security
- Which Documents Should Be Included in the Application File?
How Is the LLMC 1976 System Applied in Türkiye?
The 1996 Protocol amended the 1976 Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims. The 1996 Protocol entered into force for Türkiye on 17 October 2010. The amendments adopted by the IMO in 2012, which increased the limits, entered into force on 8 June 2015.
Articles 1328–1335 of the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TCC) incorporate the limitation regime into Turkish law. Articles 1342–1349 of the TCC also apply to the constitution and effects of the fund. Under Article 1329 of the TCC, this system may also apply to cases involving no foreign element.
The Convention does not apply only to the person appearing in the register as owner. Depending on the circumstances, the shipowner, charterer, manager, operator, salvor, persons for whose acts they are responsible and the liability insurer may be entitled to limit liability. Every application should document the nature of the claim and the applicant’s capacity under the LLMC.
Which Maritime Claims May Be Subject to Limitation?
Claims for loss of life or personal injury directly connected with the operation of the ship, loss of or property damage, losses resulting from delay and certain other losses arising otherwise than under contract may be subject to limitation under Article 2 of the LLMC. Damage to harbour works, basins, navigable waterways and aids to navigation may also fall within the system where the relevant conditions are met.
Not every maritime claim is subject to limitation. Article 1331 of the TCC excludes in Türkiye the claims under Article 2(1)(d) and (e) of the LLMC concerning the raising, removal, destruction or rendering harmless of a ship which is sunk, wrecked, stranded or abandoned, and the removal, destruction or rendering harmless of the cargo of the ship. Consequently, wreck and cargo removal costs should not automatically be included within the general limit for ‘other claims’.
The claims listed in Article 3 of the LLMC are also excluded from the limitation regime. These include claims for salvage, general average contributions and certain oil-pollution and nuclear-damage claims governed by specific international or national regimes. Where claims of different legal character are advanced in the same incident, each claim should be classified separately.
When Is the Right to Limit Liability Lost?
A liable person may lose the right to limit liability if it is proved that the loss resulted from that person’s personal act or omission, committed with the intent to cause such loss, or recklessly and with knowledge that such loss would probably result. This standard sets a higher threshold of proof than ordinary fault.
For a legal person, it is also necessary to determine which natural person’s conduct is attributable to the entity. Article 1343 of the TCC provides a framework concerning the governing bodies, partners, part-owners, ship’s manager and authorised representatives. It should not be assumed, without investigating the incident, that the right to limit has been lost merely because of a culpable act by a member of staff.
Current LLMC Limits of Liability
The general limits, increased by the 2012 amendments and in force since 8 June 2015, are calculated based on the ship’s gross tonnage and the category of claim. ‘GT’ means the ship’s gross tonnage, while ‘SDR’ means the Special Drawing Right defined by the International Monetary Fund.
| Claim category | Base limit up to 2,000 GT | 2,001–30,000 GT | 30,001–70,000 GT | Over 70,000 GT |
| Loss of life or personal injury | 3.02 million SDR | 1,208 SDR per ton | 906 SDR per ton | 604 SDR per ton |
| Other claims | 1.51 million SDR | 604 SDR per ton | 453 SDR per ton | 302 SDR per ton |
The additional amounts in the table are calculated progressively. For example, for a ship of 35,000 GT, the tranche up to 30,000 tons and the tranche from 30,001 to 35,000 tons are calculated separately and added to the relevant base limit. If the fund allocated to claims for loss of life or personal injury is insufficient, the LLMC’s distribution rules also apply.
For claims arising from the death of or personal injury to passengers on the ship, the limit is determined by multiplying the ship’s certified passenger-carrying capacity by 175,000 SDR per passenger. The passenger certificate and evidence linking the incident to the carriage of passengers should therefore be included in the calculation file.
Ship-Specific Limits in Türkiye
The amount of 83,500 SDR in Article 1332 of the TCC is not a general limit for all ships of less than 300 GT and all claims. This specific amount applies to ‘other claims’ in respect of certain ships within Article 15(2)(b) of the LLMC; the LLMC limits continue to apply in other cases.
Article 1333 of the TCC establishes a separate regime for drilling ships. Provided that the claim arose while the ship was at the drilling site for the purpose of drilling operations, a limit of 32 million SDR applies to claims for loss of life or personal injury and 20 million SDR to other claims. Check the nature of the ship and its use and location at the time of the incident.
Is It Mandatory to Constitute a Fund?
Under Article 1335 of the TCC, the right to limit liability may be invoked in an action or enforcement proceeding without constituting a fund. Consequently, Türkiye does not require a fund to be constituted in advance to limit liability in every case.
A fund may nevertheless be a powerful procedural tool. It can bring numerous claims arising from the same incident into a single pool, manage distribution among claimants and, where the conditions are met, support an application for the release of the ship or other property from arrest and the discharge of security. The decision to constitute a fund should take into account the number of claims, whether the ship is under arrest, the security already in place and proceedings in different jurisdictions.
Procedure for Constituting a Fund in Türkiye
Under Article 11 of the LLMC, a fund may be constituted in any State Party in which legal proceedings are instituted in respect of a claim against a person entitled to limit liability. In Türkiye, the application is made to a court. In practice, the following preparatory work should be completed before the application:
- The applicant’s entitlement to limit liability under the LLMC and connection with the incident are explained;
- The applicable limit is calculated by reference to the ship’s tonnage certificate, the categories of claim and, where relevant, the passenger capacity;
- Interest accruing from the date of the occurrence giving rise to liability until the date on which the fund is constituted is added to the limitation amount;
- The fund amount is deposited in cash, or security that the court considers adequate is provided;
- It is stated that the fund is a common fund for claims arising from the same occurrence and within the same liability group; and
- A list of known claimants is submitted to the court together with details of pending actions, enforcement proceedings, arrests and security.
The fund is constituted in the aggregate amount calculated under the LLMC. A fund constituted by one of the persons entitled to limit liability in respect of the same occurrence, or by the insurer, may, where the conditions are met, be treated as a common fund for the persons concerned. Under Article 1342 of the TCC, if no fund has been constituted on behalf of a legal person, ordinary partnership or shipowning partnership, a person who may be held personally liable for the relevant debt may also constitute a fund in the aggregate limitation amount; a lower fund proportionate to that person’s partnership share may not be constituted.
Cash or Security
Article 11 of the LLMC allows the fund to be constituted by depositing the limit plus interest calculated up to the date of constitution, or by providing security the court considers adequate. The court assesses whether security such as a bank guarantee or a P&I Club letter of undertaking is acceptable based on its wording and conditions; not every form of security is automatically adequate.
Under Article 1347 of the TCC, a fund constituted in cash is held in an interest-bearing account until distribution is completed. Once the court accepts limitation of liability, no further interest may accrue on the portion of a claim exceeding the limit of liability.
How Are the Court’s Subject-Matter and Territorial Jurisdiction Determined?
Under Article 1348 of the TCC, the court with subject-matter jurisdiction over the constitution of a fund is the commercial court of first instance with jurisdiction over maritime matters. Where no such court exists, the application is heard by the commercial court of first instance designated for that purpose or, if there is none, by the civil court of first instance so designated.
Territorial jurisdiction depends on the ship’s registration and flag status:
- For an unregistered Turkish ship, the court of the owner’s domicile
- For a foreign ship, the Istanbul Commercial Court of First Instance responsible for maritime matters
- For a ship registered in a Turkish Ship Registry, the court under whose supervision the registry is maintained
Filing the fund in the wrong court may cause delays and additional security costs. Before applying, review the ship’s registration, ownership information and any existing proceedings in Türkiye concerning a foreign ship.
Effect of the Fund on Claims and Security
The fund is reserved exclusively for paying claims for which liability may be limited. Under Article 1346 of the TCC, claimants with claims not subject to limitation may not claim against the fund; if a balance remains after distribution, the other creditors of the person who constituted the fund may enforce against that balance.
As a rule, claims are distributed in proportion to the amounts admitted against the fund. Without prejudice to the rights arising under the LLMC in respect of claims for loss of life or personal injury, Article 1334 of the TCC gives certain claims relating to harbour works, basins, navigable waterways and aids to navigation priority over other property claims. Distribution is therefore not merely a percentage calculation; the category of claim and any statutory priority must also be determined.
Under Article 1345 of the TCC, once the fund court admits a claim against the fund, it discharges any real or personal security relating to that claim. Any rankings previously conferred by such security are not preserved in the fund’s distribution. The release of the ship or other property must, however, be considered in accordance with the conditions in Article 13 of the LLMC, the place where the fund was constituted and the relevant court order; an application to constitute a fund does not, by itself, automatically lift every arrest.
Legal proceedings and enforcement costs do not fall within the fund limit. Under Article 1349 of the TCC, liability for these costs may not be limited, and the debtor may be required to pay them separately.
Which Documents Should Be Included in the Application File?
The contents of the fund application file vary according to the circumstances of the incident. At the initial stage, collecting the following documents and records may expedite the calculation and review of security:
- Proof of cash payment or the full text of the proposed security
- List of known claims, including their type, amount and legal basis
- Ship registry entry, tonnage certificate and owner or operator details
- Certified evidence of passenger capacity, if a passenger claim is made
- Marine casualty reports, logbook entries and a chronology of the incident
- Documents relating to security and representation provided by the insurer or P&I Club
- Calculation of interest from the date of the occurrence to the date of constitution of the fund
- Decisions relating to existing actions, enforcement proceedings, precautionary attachments and proceedings in other countries
In conclusion, in matters concerning the establishment of a limitation fund following a maritime casualty or the release of existing arrests, obtaining professional legal assistance is of particular importance, as an incorrect calculation of the limitation amount, the inclusion of a claim falling outside the scope of limitation in the fund or an application to a court lacking jurisdiction may prolong the period for which the vessel remains under arrest and increase the cost of security.
If you require further information on this subject, please do not hesitate to contact us using the contact details below.
Relevant Contacts
| Selçuk Esenyel Founding and Managing Partner Tel: +90 212 397 19 91 Fax: +90 212 397 19 92 Mob: +90 506 792 76 90 | Türker Yıldırım Partner Tel: +90 212 397 19 91 Fax: +90 212 397 19 92 Mob: +90 505 650 47 24 |
| Ali Nihad Özgürel Team Leader nihad.ozgurel@esenyelpartners.com Tel: +90 212 397 19 91 Fax: +90 212 397 19 92 Mob: +90 539 896 46 66 | |